Posted by: thebuffyrewatch | June 26, 2011

Cordia’s Review: S2, E18 – Killed By Death

Killed by Death
Season 2, Episode 18
Original airing: 3/3/98

My Rating: 66

The Good: This Monster-of-the-Week is actually an interesting premise in this episode. Buffy is hospitalized and learns children are dying and no one really knows why. But the kids say Death himself is coming for them. The demon is quite creepy and well costumed/acted. The fact that only the children can see him makes him an interesting analogy for Buffy’s desire to always be fighting something. Especially since even the Scoobies don’t believe he’s real at first.

We also get to see an interesting slice of Buffy’s life where she is sick and relatively helpless. She can’t even keep up with Angel at the beginning of the episode. And yet, she heals from it all very quickly, which is a nice nod from the doctor to her slayer powers.

And, as always, the characters shine through. Xander and Cordelia in particular get their relationship examined a bit. They are both  jealous of the other at some point and Cordelia even has a legitimate reason as she points out Xander’s continuing crush on Buffy. But an accord is reached with the very underwritten and sweet scene where Cordelia brings Xander coffee and donuts. No matter what, they know they work together.

Finally, Angelus remains a force in this episode. After his destruction in Passion (S2E17), it’s nice to see him stepping up again instead withdrawing to the shadows as he did after Innocence (S2E14). He’s not overly involved here, but he is the reason for the change of setting to a hospital and his attempt to “visit” Buffy is a wonderful moment for Xander to step up.

The Bad:  It was a bit disappointing to be introduced to such a wonderful analogy of Buffy’s psyche, then to have it all be a monster anyway. Cordelia brings up that Buffy might be inventing this monster so she has something to fight since she can’t fight natural causes. The concept itself is brilliant, but unfortunately, ends up false. This has happened before in Ted (S2E11), where the writers touched on the brilliance of a new man in Joyce’s life and the effect of that on Buffy as well as Buffy “killing” a human. But in the end, Ted turned out to be a homicidal robot, so the impact was a bit lost. I understand this is a genre show and sometimes the cerebral has to be outweighed with a bit of violence, but it still feels like a bit of a backtrack when such brilliance is almost realized.

The show relies on a heavy conceit in this episode that Willow is a complete and utter medical genius. I’m always willing to believe Willow can do anything with a computer, but to also believe she’s extensively studied medicine to the point where she can instantaneously see and understand an involved and progressed medical experiment to the point of safely dosing Buffy with an unmeasured about of a highly lethal virus is really too much. It’s distracting and disappointing that the writers couldn’t come up with something a bit cleverer.

But the major disappointment in this episode was the dispatching of the demon himself. He’s actually built up pretty well and comes across as rather scary, especially with the sense of self-confidence he projects and his casual backhand to Buffy when he kills the doctor. Even the fight at the end is coming out in the demon’s favor, till weakened, delirious Buffy reaches up at the last second and casually snaps the demon’s neck. It’s incredibly anti-climactic and unrealistic. Perhaps a full strength Buffy can snap a neck with a simple twist of the wrist, but even full power Angelus had to give Jenny’s neck a pretty good twist in the last episode. It’s just not that easy to break someone’s spinal cord. And it does, of course, lead to comparisons with Jenny’s death of the previous episode. Having two people/demons dispatched in the same manner in two concurrent episodes feels like the writers just weren’t trying.

Favorite Moment: Angelus “visits” the hospital to torment Buffy, but Xander is there to keep him from entering the room. The conversation between these two is very powerful and very painful, but Xander’s determination to stare down Angelus is admirable and well-acted. We can see he knows if Angelus decides to get past him, Xander will most likely die, but when it comes to protecting Buffy, he’s willing to make the sacrifice.

The Bottom Line: This is a fine follow-up to Passion and much better than many Monster-of-the-Week episodes. But the problems mentioned in The Bad do weigh it down and keep it from being any more than merely good.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: